Trending Now
Do WNBA Players Really Want to Be Paid...
America’s Syrian Civil War
A separatist movement is brewing in Canada
Modern Monetary Theory
An Open Letter to Treasury Secretary Bessent
Private Property and Customer Safety: Starbucks Learns a...
Game Theory
Learning from the Caribbean CBDC Experience
States Are Streamlining Licensing—ICE Is Kicking In Windows
Trump Has Completely Dropped His “Populist” Act
  • About Us
  • Contacts
  • Email Whitelisting
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
DailyProfitTips.com
  • Editor’s Pick
  • Economy
  • Investing
  • Politics
  • World News
Editor's PickInvesting

Ellingburg v. United States Brief: Criminal Restitution Counts as Criminal Punishment

by June 30, 2025
June 30, 2025

Matthew Cavedon

prison

In 1995, when petitioner Holsey Ellingburg, Jr., robbed a bank, federal criminal restitution was governed by the Victim and Witness Protection Act (VWPA). The VWPA provided that a defendant’s liability to pay restitution ended twenty years after the entry of judgment. Then, in 1996, Congress enacted the Mandatory Victim Restitution Act (MVRA), which extended the liability period to twenty years after a defendant’s release from imprisonment and required that restitution include interest. The MVRA’s drafters apparently anticipated the possibility that its retroactive application might violate the Constitution’s Ex Post Facto Clause: Congress explicitly made the Act retroactive only “to the extent constitutionally permissible.”

The issue in this case is whether that concern was correct. 
Holsey Ellingburg’s sentence included just shy of 27 years’ imprisonment and $7,567.25 in restitution. He paid $2,054.04 toward this during the twenty years authorized by the VWPA. In the past three years, he has returned to society, living with his fiancée and trying to make ends meet. However, his probation officer maintains that he still has to make $100 monthly restitution payments, and the government says he now owes $13,476.01 total—almost twice as much as his sentence originally imposed and far more than he owed at the close of the VWPA restitution period.
Ellingburg sought judicial relief. The district court held that the MVRA’s extension of the restitution period did not increase his punishment. The Eighth Circuit instead applied its own precedent holding that criminal restitution is not subject to the Ex Post Facto Clause at all because it is a civil remedy rather than a criminal punishment. Two of the three panel members wrote a concurring opinion criticizing this precedent, but the Eighth Circuit denied rehearing en banc.
After the Supreme Court granted Ellingburg’s cert petition, the government decided not to defend the Eighth Circuit’s decision and to instead file a brief in support of Ellingburg. Cato and the Fines and Fees Justice Center are pleased to file a brief that joins the parties in asking the Court to vacate the decision. 
Criminal restitution is punishment under the Court’s modern precedent. Historical authorities support this conclusion. While those are adequate reasons to rule in Ellingburg’s favor, the Court should also revive a broader understanding of what qualifies as criminal punishment more broadly, revisiting issues like sex-offender registration, monetary penalties, and civil asset forfeiture.
previous post
This Harm Reduction Innovation Is Already Saving Lives
next post
CAFE Standards

Related Posts

Learning from the Caribbean CBDC Experience

July 24, 2025

States Are Streamlining Licensing—ICE Is Kicking In Windows

July 24, 2025

PAGCOR first-half gross gaming revenue hits P215B

July 24, 2025

Davao bus project targeted for pilot operations in...

July 24, 2025

Hotel industry urges traveler-safety focus in promoting PHL...

July 24, 2025

Employers warned against coercing workers to show up...

July 24, 2025

SES in talks to bring satellite telco coverage...

July 24, 2025

PHL corn output seen rising on improved pest...

July 24, 2025

2024 healthcare spending rises to 5.9% of GDP

July 24, 2025

Chairman Lee, other officers take charge at FPI

July 24, 2025
Enter Your Information Below To Receive Free Trading Ideas, Latest News And Articles.

    Your information is secure and your privacy is protected. By opting in you agree to receive emails from us. Remember that you can opt-out any time, we hate spam too!
    • About Us
    • Contacts
    • Email Whitelisting
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms and Conditions

    Copyright © 2025 DailyProfitTips.com All Rights Reserved.

    DailyProfitTips.com
    • Editor’s Pick
    • Economy
    • Investing
    • Politics
    • World News